To the real film fanatic, this phrase should look familiar. You may recognise it as one of the key sentences Tom Cruise spoke to Renee Zellweger in Jerry Maguire. It’s when he explains why he wants to stay with his wife: because she completes him as a person.
Oprah Winfrey once dismissed this as not being realistic. She did a show on unrealistic expectations of marriage. When her guest, a marriage counselor, gave a list of unrealistic expectations of marriage, Oprah was reminded of Jerry Maguire and said something like “Oh, so it’s not like in Jerry Maguire, where …” and she mentioned this as an example of an unrealistic expectation of marriage.
This is hard for me to say, because I happen to like Oprah and her shows very much.* But I disagree with her on this. Strongly. And, naturally, I’ll tell you why.
Have you seen Jerry Maguire? It’s about this sports manager (Tom Cruise) who gets fired because of his ideals, and who, on leaving his employer, takes a financial secretary (Renee Zellweger) with him who is really impressed with him. The next phase in his and her life is difficult, with a lot of financial problems. His only client, played by Cuba Gooding Jr. (who got an Oscar for best actor in a supporting role for this), made a real impression on Tom with his devotion to his wife and children. And when money got tight, Tom decided to ask his lovely assistant to marry him. “We can save a lot on health insurance”, is his excuse. Renee doesn’t care, for she is hopelessly in love with him, and he is great with her young son.
Cuba warns him that he isn’t doing it right. “You didn’t have the talk, did you?” he says. His manager never did mention love when the decision to get married was made. And sure enough, the two spouses seem to grow somewhat apart. Or, rather, Renee realises that they never really were that much together (in an emotional sense) from the start. And they decide to take a break from each other.
But then something great happens. And suddenly Tom realises that the most important moments in his life are only as great as they can be if he can share them with his wife. He breaks off the long business trip that was intended to be “a break from each other” to go tell his wife what he has learned about his feelings. And he introduces his explanation that he misses her and wants her with the words “I’m not letting you get rid of me.” (If you break out in tears easily, don’t watch this part, because this is the tear jerker scene…) And then he explains that although he had a great night, it wasn’t really so great as it could have been because she was not there to share it with him. And he ends with “You complete me”, a phrase he picked up from two lovers in an elevator, something that he knew really touched his wife, but the meaning of which he was only now able to grasp.
So what do we have here? A man of the world who discovers that marriage is all about needing and complementing each other. And Oprah and her guest characterized it as being unrealistic. Why? Probably because people tend to think they should conclude from this that if they need and complement each other, married life will always be bliss, sitting on cloud nine, and that it will be absolute heaven. And that, of course, is not true. You see, the trouble with films is that they end. They end on a high, usually. At least, many American films do. (We won’t mention French and Russian films here…)
They do not show you that after Tom and Renee embrace, they will have years and years of living together with both good and bad times. They are likely to have rows, disagreements, sickness, financial problems, concerns about children and other matters. But they are also likely to have times when they enjoy each other’s company, times of comforting each other, strengthening and supporting each other, and times when they really enjoy their children.
And this, Oprah, is what I think marriage is all about. This is perfectly realistic. There is nothing wrong with saying you need your spouse, that he or she completes you (and you him or her, let’s not forget that part!), as long as you realise that this does not mean just absolute bliss. You should be prepared to have both good and bad times. Just as long as you keep in mind that having bad times does not mean your marriage is bad. Just as long as you do not think that a disagreement or row means that the foundations of your marriage are crumbling beneath you.
This is illustrated in a really good and even humorous way, in The Story of Us. Subheading underneath the title on one of the film posters is “Can a marriage survive fifteen years of marriage?” In the description of the storyline on TheStoryOfUs.net I found these highly interesting questions: “How can qualities that were once so endearing become so infuriating that you lose sight of what is important?” And – here it comes, Oprah! – “At what point do you forget that without the other person you are incomplete?” (Emphasis added by me.) One of the producers/writers of the film was Jessie Nelson. She said this about the way she sees marriage, a view which is illustrated very well by the film: “No one ever told me how hard it would be. You fall in and out of love. There are magical times, and then there are challenging times.” For both main characters, Ben (Bruce Willis) and Katie Jordan (Michelle Pfeiffer), fighting has become the condition rather than the exception. They believe that their only option is a trial separation. During their time apart, both Ben and Katie reflect on the value of their shared history. They contemplate the “dance”, perfected over time, that has made them an “us.” I won’t give away how the film ends. But whatever happens, the story gives you a good idea of how important it is to be realistic and take the bad with the good. And how it is possible to be committed to your spouse without you or him/her being the “perfect partner” – who is a fictitious character, anyhow, even outside the film.
I conclude from both films and from real life experience that you can be both romantic and realistic. You can be realistic and still like Jerry Maguire. You can be realistic and have a good marriage, a great “Story of Us”. You can have both good and bad times, and not lose hope. You can have both good and bad times, and still be happy some of the time. No, not all of the time, because that is definitely not realistic!
* What do you mean, I’m a man? Of course I am. Should that stop me from liking Oprah? Absolutely not. I’m like that. When I’m in America, you can tell I’m like that by looking at the TV channels I watch. I don’t like “Movies for men who like movies” very much, but I do like “Life, the women’s channel”. And no, I’m not gay. I’m just a bit more sensitive, perhaps, than most men I know, or than they like to appear to be. And so I also like Oprah.
Note – just to satisfy your curiosity: Yes, I’m married, and have been since 1982. We have three children.
(Previously published as ‘Conrad’s Column.)’